There’s a newly opened car park on Bedford Rd in Ringwood next to the railway station. It’s one of many new car parks being built near train stations. There’s a difference. Nearby station car parks such as Mooroolbark were funded and constructed as part of Victoria’s Big Build project. In contrast, the Bedford Road car park was funded by the previous federal government’s Car Park Rorts Affair.
It’s a revenue trap. A premeditated and well thought-out trap at that.
How does the trap work? It uses every trick possible to present like a post-paid parking system. When it is, in fact, pre-paid.
The parking inspectors patrol the car park with such cadence that you don’t stand a chance.
The entry sign

The entry sign mimics that of a typical post-paid parking system:
- The rate is presented as a price-tier table based on on the length of stay.
- There is a free parking period.
- There is a daily price cap.
- It states that parking only needs to be registered (not paid) on arrival.
- The sign is not consistent with pre-paid street parking within any local council.
- The sign is visually similar to the post-paid parking at Maroondah Hospital that is operated by the same council.
Additional to this, there are several dark patterns which make this signage misleading:
- The prices are incorrect. Parking is actually charged at a flat rate of $2.00/hr in 30 minute blocks. 3 to 3.5 hours costs $1.00. 4 to 4.5 hours costs $3.00. The daily maximum applies after 5.5 hours, not 5.
- The words “must register on arrival” appear under the free rate. The words “pay on arrival” do not appear beneath the rates thereafter, or anywhere.
- The sign states that penalties apply for overstaying, but does not define what “overstaying” means. The car park closes at midnight. It would be reasonable to assume that penalties apply to vehicles that are parked overnight.
- This is positioned in a signed no-stopping zone. It is on the passenger side of the vehicle, in a small font. You are not legally allowed to stop to read it, and you definitely cannot scan the QR code with your phone. This sign cannot be fully interpreted at rolling pace. It may sound absurd, but this council once fined me for stopping for around 15 seconds in one of these zones.
The parking meter
Every pre-paid parking meter I have ever used has done two things:
- Ask how long I’m planning to stay.
- Ask for payment.
The meter at this particular car park does neither of these things. I’ll run you through the flow:

This is the welcome screen.
There is text over the text.
The parking rates do not match the printed signage. It does not mention a free parking period.
It has conflicting instructions on where to touch to start.
It is an ugly screen.

You’re asked to enter your registration plate number, which is quite normal for a parking meter that does not print a physical ticket.
The keyboard layout is jarring.
This is the only screen with a help button.
The clock shows 06:54 when it’s actually 18:54.

The next screen tells you that there’s 180 minutes of free parking remaining, and when the free parking period ends.
It has not asked how long you intend to park.
There is no question presented to the user. This screen is purely informational.
So you click “Continue”.
Note: There is a bit of text that says “180 minutes available”. The sign at the entrance implies that daily cap is reached 120 minutes after the free period ends (5 hours). The math doesn’t math.

You’re asked if you want an eReceipt.
You were never even asked to pay.
You haven’t been told what an eReceipt is or why you would need it.
You can’t navigate back. There is no help, so you click “No”.

This is the final screen.
It’s almost identical to the “Free time remaining” screen.
It confirms a payment that never occurred for a period of time you were not asked about.
Inexplicably, there is a “Continue” button.
At this point it says you’re all done, so you run to catch your train.
Upon your return
If you fell for the trap, you’ll return to the car park and attempt to pay at the meter. After entering your registration plate, you’re expecting a payment flow. Instead, you get this:

Huh?
It’s asking how long I want to park for.
Why now? Why not when I first parked?
It’s 7PM, and it says it’s already paid until 10:25PM. It previously said it was free until 9:54PM.
How is it $1.00 when the first tier is $2.00?
Whatever. I’ll just pay $1.00 and go.
At this point, you return to your car and find an infringement taped to the windscreen.

It turns out the daily cap isn’t $6.00. It’s actually $105.00.
The offence is “Fail to pay fee and obey instructions on sign/meter”. The sign only stated that I needed to register on arrival. The instructions on the meter were followed. A payment was made before departure. I’m not sure this fine is going to stand up in court.
Follow the Money
Take a deep dive into Maroondah Council’s annual report (mirror).
Fine revenue increased from $1,814,000 in 2025 to $2,669,000 in 2026. – Page 200
The favourable variance of $1.03 million for statutory fees and fines is mainly due to a $0.51 million increase in parking fines resulting from increased weekend patrols. – Page 192
That’s a 47% YoY increase, and half of it was from parking fines.
The $33.2 million project was jointly funded by the Australian Government ($29.7 million) and Council ($3.5 million) – Page 68
This is interesting, considering that the original budget was $15 million. Still, the council could recoup their share in a few years of fines alone.
It’s clear that the council makes more money off people who don’t pay for parking than those who do.
Free Time Remaining

I’m going to circle back to that horrible screen…
The “Free time remaining” page actually contradicts the documented flow on the council’s own website.
The website states that after entering your number plate, you get prompted for how long you want to park.
That’s a lie.

Leave a Reply